Garshick's pick is the Hero Cosmetics Mighty Patch Original. "This hydrocolloid option helps to draw out excess fluid and keep you from picking at your pimples, which is particularly important for the deeper, hormonal breakouts," she says.
After you've done the deed (or after patching, if you're one who has self-control), cleanse and dry your face, then blend a "rice-sized" amount of Rescue Balm onto the affected area, reapplying once or twice per day until the breakout goes away. The vitamin E in it helps to improve the appearance of scarring.